faith · hope · loveBears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, and endures all things.1 Corinthians 13:7Daily verses
Skip to main content
Holiday offer: 50% off 508(c)(1)(A) trust packages through December 31.See the packages
508ministry.com
Caiaphas: High priest who presided over the council that handed Jesus to Pilate

508 Daily Verse · Bible people

Caiaphas

High priest who presided over the council that handed Jesus to Pilate

High priest c. AD 18-36/37 · 15 min read

The office he held

When the Gospels say "the high priest," they mean the single most powerful Jewish person alive in the first century, below the king or the Roman governor. In earlier centuries the high priest was a sacred office held for life by a descendant of Aaron, the brother of Moses. He alone entered the innermost room of the Temple, the Holy of Holies, once a year on the Day of Atonement, to make atonement for the nation's sin (Leviticus 16). He presided over the Sanhedrin, the council of seventy-one elders, priests, and scribes that acted as the highest Jewish court on questions of religious law and a good deal of local administration.

By the time of Jesus, the office had been twisted by politics. The Hasmonean kings, and then Herod the Great, appointed and removed high priests at will. Herod went so far as to bring in men from Egypt and Babylon with no claim to the position, because he wanted priests who owed everything to him. After Herod's son Archelaus lost his throne in AD 6, the Roman governors took over the right to appoint. In that environment the high priest was both a religious leader and a Roman appointee. He was responsible for the Temple, its money, and its calm, and he had to answer to the prefect when crowds got out of hand. Every year at Passover, hundreds of thousands of pilgrims crowded Jerusalem, many of them nursing hopes of a king who would drive out Rome. The high priest's duty was to keep that city from boiling over.

How Caiaphas rose

Josephus gives us a short, dry record of the high priests in this period. The prefect Valerius Gratus removed Annas, who had served from about AD 6 to 15, and then appointed in turn Ishmael son of Phabi, Eleazar son of Annas, and Simon son of Kamithos, each for about a year. Finally, he appointed "Joseph, who was also called Caiaphas" (Antiquities 18.34 to 35). Josephus says nothing about why Gratus settled on this man, but the choice worked. Caiaphas stayed in office for about eighteen years, through the whole of Pontius Pilate's term as prefect and until Vitellius, the governor of Syria, removed him shortly after Pilate himself was recalled. A man does not keep the post for eighteen years under the Romans unless he is skilled at the work and trusted by the governor. That tells us something about his character that the Gospels do not say directly: Caiaphas was a capable political operator.

His connections also helped. John tells us he was the son-in-law of Annas (John 18:13). Annas had been deposed, but he kept great influence. Five of his sons and a son-in-law all became high priests, which is an astonishing record, and Luke still calls Annas "high priest" in the same breath as Caiaphas (Luke 3:2; Acts 4:6). The family was wealthy and, according to some Jewish sources, widely resented. A line in the Talmud complains about the house of Annas: "Woe is me because of the house of Hanan, woe is me because of their whisperings" (Pesachim 57a). We should treat that as one side of a long argument, not a neutral report, but it shows that the priestly aristocracy had a reputation for power and greed in the generation that followed.

Caiaphas and his circle belonged to the Sadducees, the priestly party that controlled the Temple. The Sadducees accepted only the written Torah as authoritative, rejected belief in the resurrection of the dead, and were generally friendlier toward the Romans than the Pharisees, who emphasized oral tradition and personal holiness. That detail is important for reading the Gospels and Acts. When the Sadducees heard the apostles preaching Jesus's resurrection, Acts says they were "greatly annoyed" and had them arrested (Acts 4:1 to 3; 5:17).

The ossuary

In November 1990, workers building a water park in the Peace Forest south of the Old City of Jerusalem broke into a burial cave. Inside were twelve ossuaries, small limestone boxes used in the first century to hold the bones of the dead after the flesh had decayed. One of them was unusually fine, with a carved rosette pattern. It bore the Aramaic inscription "Yehosef bar Qayafa," that is, "Joseph son of Caiaphas." Inside were the bones of six people, including a man about sixty years old.

A carved limestone ossuary found in a burial cave south of Jerusalem bears the name Joseph son of Caiaphas. Stand-in image being painted. Our painted artwork is being upgraded, stay tuned.

Archaeologists, including Ronny Reich and Zvi Greenhut who studied the find, concluded that this was probably the family tomb of the priestly house of Caiaphas, and possibly the burial of the high priest himself. Other scholars are more careful. The name Joseph was common, and "Caiaphas" might refer to someone else in the family. The honest summary is that the tomb is almost certainly connected to the family, and it may be the man we read about in the Gospels, though the matter is debated. In any case it is the kind of material evidence that shows the Gospel names belong to the real streets and families of Jerusalem. The ossuary is displayed at the Israel Museum.

Caiaphas in the Gospels: the plot

The first time we meet Caiaphas by name is in John 11, right after Jesus raised Lazarus from the dead at Bethany. The miracle caused a stir. Many people believed, and the chief priests and Pharisees called an emergency session of the council. "What are we to do?" they said. "For this man performs many signs. If we let him go on like this, everyone will believe in him, and the Romans will come and take away both our place and our nation" (John 11:47 to 48).

Notice what the council fears. They are not primarily worried about false teaching. They are worried about Rome. A popular movement centered on a miracle worker could be read by the Roman governor as a revolt. If Rome crushed it, the Romans would take away the Temple, the council, and their position. The Jewish historian Josephus later wrote about how that exact fear played out when the Romans destroyed Jerusalem in AD 70. The council's fear was not paranoid. It was grounded in what Rome did to rebels.

Then Caiaphas speaks. "You know nothing at all," he says. "Nor do you understand that it is better for you that one man should die for the people, not that the whole nation should perish" (John 11:49 to 50). It is a cold piece of political arithmetic, the kind of reasoning that has justified injustice in every age: sacrifice one innocent person to preserve the many.

Caiaphas speaks before the council: it is better that one man should die for the people (John 11:49-50). Stand-in image being painted. Our painted artwork is being upgraded, stay tuned.

Then John adds one of the most striking comments in the Gospels. He says Caiaphas "did not say this of his own accord, but being high priest that year he prophesied that Jesus would die for the nation, and not for the nation only, but also to gather into one the children of God who are scattered abroad" (John 11:51 to 52). Without knowing it, the high priest had described what Jesus's death would mean. That is the deepest irony in the story. Caiaphas meant, "Let us get rid of this troublemaker." God meant, "This one will die in the place of the people." John notes that the high priest of that year spoke with a prophetic gift that went with the office, even though the man himself was not seeking God's will. From that day, John says, the leaders "made plans to put him to death" (John 11:53).

Matthew gives a parallel scene. Shortly before Passover the chief priests and elders gathered "in the palace of the high priest, who was called Caiaphas, and plotted together in order to arrest Jesus by stealth and kill him. But they said, 'Not during the feast, lest there be an uproar among the people'" (Matthew 26:3 to 5). They wanted to avoid a riot. They got their opportunity when Judas Iscariot, one of the Twelve, came to them and offered to hand Jesus over for thirty pieces of silver (Matthew 26:14 to 16; the Twelve).

Caiaphas in the Gospels: the night trial

After the arrest in the garden of Gethsemane, soldiers took Jesus first to Annas, and then to Caiaphas (John 18:12 to 14, 24). The Gospels differ in detail about the sequence of the night, but they agree on the main facts: Jesus was brought to the high priest's house, and the council gathered in the middle of the night, which was itself irregular. Later Jewish legal writings, though they come from a later date and may not describe exactly what happened in AD 30, forbid capital trials at night and during feasts. Whether those rules were in force then is debated. What the Gospels say is that the council was in a hurry and the witnesses disagreed.

Soldiers bring Jesus to the high priest's house in the middle of the night (John 18:12-14, 24). Stand-in image being painted. Our painted artwork is being upgraded, stay tuned.

Matthew tells us that "the chief priests and the whole council were seeking false testimony against Jesus that they might put him to death, but they found none, though many false witnesses came forward" (Matthew 26:59 to 60). At last two came and said that Jesus claimed he could destroy the Temple and rebuild it in three days. Caiaphas stood and asked Jesus whether he had no answer. Jesus was silent. Then the high priest put the central question: "I adjure you by the living God, tell us if you are the Christ, the Son of God" (Matthew 26:63).

Jesus answered with words from the book of Daniel and from the Psalms: "You have said so. But I tell you, from now on you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of Power and coming on the clouds of heaven" (Matthew 26:64; compare Daniel 7:13 and Psalm 110:1). In response, Caiaphas tore his robes. The gesture was a traditional sign of grief or horror at blasphemy. "He has uttered blasphemy," he said. "What further witnesses do we need? You have now heard his blasphemy. What is your judgment?" They answered, "He deserves death" (Matthew 26:65 to 66).

Here we should be careful about two things. First, the council did not have the legal authority to carry out an execution, so they took Jesus to Pontius Pilate. In doing so they changed the accusation from blasphemy to claiming to be a king, since Pilate would care about the second but not the first (Luke 23:2; see Pontius Pilate). Second, as we explain in Pilate's profile, nothing in these accounts justifies blaming Jewish people as a whole. Caiaphas and the council were a small group of men in a specific political situation. Jesus himself, his mother, his disciples, and the thousands of early believers in Jerusalem were Jewish, and many priests later believed too (Acts 6:7).

Caiaphas and the apostles

The story does not end with the crucifixion. The resurrection set the high priest's family against the apostles. In Acts 4, after Peter and John healed a lame man at the Temple gate and preached the resurrection, they were arrested and brought before "Annas the high priest and Caiaphas and John and Alexander, and all who were of the high-priestly family" (Acts 4:6). Peter spoke boldly: "There is salvation in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved" (Acts 4:12; see Peter and John). The council could not deny that a miracle had happened, since the healed man stood right there. They threatened the apostles and let them go.

A little later the high priest and the Sadducees jailed the apostles again, and an angel let them out at night. When they were brought in once more, Peter said, "We must obey God rather than men" (Acts 5:29). The council wanted to kill them. It was the Pharisee Gamaliel, the teacher who would later train Saul of Tarsus (see Paul), who spoke up: "If this plan or this undertaking is of man, it will fail; but if it is of God, you will not be able to overthrow it" (Acts 5:38 to 39). The council had the apostles beaten and released them.

Acts also shows that the high priest's authority was behind the stoning of Stephen. In Acts 7:1, the high priest asks the first question at Stephen's hearing: "Are these things so?" Scripture does not name the high priest there, but the time fits the term of Caiaphas. Later Saul himself "went to the high priest and asked him for letters to the synagogues at Damascus" (Acts 9:1 to 2). So the same office that pursued Jesus was used to chase his followers across the region (Stephen).

The end of his tenure

In AD 36 or 37, Vitellius, the Roman governor of Syria, traveled to Jerusalem, canceled a tax on the sale of produce, and removed Caiaphas as high priest, replacing him with Jonathan, a son of Annas (Josephus, Antiquities 18.90 to 95). He did so at around the same time he sent Pilate off to Rome, so the two men who had stood together on the morning of the trial left their posts together. Josephus gives no reason for Caiaphas's removal, and we do not know his fate. There is no reliable account of his death.

Later Christian legend invented stories. Some medieval writers said he died in a terrible way, or that he was banished. These are not history. The honest answer is that we do not know what became of him, only that his burial cave is probably known.

How should we judge Caiaphas?

It would be easy to turn Caiaphas into a cartoon villain. The Gospels do not do that. John gives him a thoughtful, even logical, motive, and even lets him speak a truth he did not understand. The pattern is familiar. A leader with responsibility for the safety of a community looks at a threat, decides that a hard choice is needed, and talks himself into a wrong that feels like wisdom. Caiaphas's reasoning, "better one man die than the nation perish," has been repeated by tyrants and committees throughout history.

What marks the failure is not that Caiaphas weighed the political risks but that he refused the evidence in front of him. The council admitted that Jesus performed "many signs," and they did not ask what the signs meant. Peter and John said the same thing to them later: "We cannot but speak of what we have seen and heard" (Acts 4:20). The man raised from the dead at Bethany, Lazarus, was so convincing that the chief priests even planned to kill him too (John 12:10).

For the Christian reader the story has two edges. It is a warning about how religious or political leaders can protect an institution at the cost of truth. And it is a reminder that God's plan worked through the very human failures of people like Caiaphas, not because God needed their sin, but because the cross would show that even the worst of human choices cannot defeat his purpose. Peter put it plainly in his sermon at Pentecost: Jesus was "delivered up according to the definite plan and foreknowledge of God," and the people who handed him over were still responsible for their act (Acts 2:23). Both are true at once, and the Bible does not try to explain how.

There is a note of mercy at the end of the story, too. The book of Acts records that "a great many of the priests became obedient to the faith" (Acts 6:7). The priestly class that opposed Jesus saw some of its own members follow him. The door was not closed, even to the circle of Caiaphas.

Sayings in our verse collection

The daily verse index holds no sayings spoken by Caiaphas. The verse nearest to his story is Jesus's own word spoken in Gethsemane on the night of the arrest:

  • Matthew 26:41: "Watch and pray that you may not enter into temptation. The spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak."

Caiaphas's own recorded words, all from the Gospel of John and Matthew, are few: "You know nothing at all. Nor do you understand that it is better for you that one man should die for the people, not that the whole nation should perish" (John 11:49 to 50), and the question, "I adjure you by the living God, tell us if you are the Christ, the Son of God" (Matthew 26:63).

Verses from our index

No verse spoken by Caiaphas is in the index. Matthew 26:41 is Jesus in Gethsemane on the night of the arrest.

Matthew 26:41

Watch and pray, that ye enter not into temptation: the spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak.

The spirit is willing but the flesh is weak. Watch and pray, and be gentle with yourself.

Places

Map of places in the life of CaiaphasDead SeaDead SeaJerusalem Temple1House of the high priest (Mount Zion)2Peace Forest tomb3Bethany4
  1. 1Jerusalem Temple · Where Caiaphas presided over Temple service
  2. 2House of the high priest (Mount Zion) · Traditional site of the night hearing
  3. 3Peace Forest tomb · Family ossuary found here in 1990
  4. 4Bethany · Lazarus raised; the plot begins (John 11)
Map drawn by 508 Ministry from Natural Earth public-domain data. Locations of ancient sites are approximate; some identifications are traditional.
  • The house of the high priest on Mount Zion, where the night hearing took place, traditionally marked by the Church of St. Peter in Gallicantu
  • The Temple Mount, where Caiaphas presided over the Temple service
  • The Peace Forest tomb, south of the Old City, where the family ossuary was found
  • Bethany, where Lazarus was raised and the plot began

By the numbers

High priests under Valerius Gratus and Pilate, approximate years in office (AD) Josephus, Antiquities 18.34-35. Annas about AD 6-15; Gratus then appointed Ishmael, Eleazar and Simon, each for about a year, then Caiaphas. Years are rounded approximations. Source: gutenberg.org.

Timeline

  1. 6Annas begins as high priest (Roman appointment)Josephus, Ant. 18.26
  2. 15Valerius Gratus removes Annas and appoints a series of high priestsJosephus, Ant. 18.34
  3. 18Joseph Caiaphas appointed high priestJosephus, Ant. 18.35
  4. 30Council meets after Lazarus is raised; Jesus tried by nightJohn 11:47-53; Matthew 26:57-68
  5. 33Peter and John brought before Annas and CaiaphasActs 4:5-6
  6. 36Vitellius removes Caiaphas; Jonathan son of Annas appointedJosephus, Ant. 18.90-95
Dates before the first century are approximate; Scripture references open the World English Bible.

People in this story

Go deeper

Josephus's Antiquities books 18 and 20 list the high priests of this era. Alfred Edersheim's The Temple: Its Ministry and Services (linked below) describes in detail what a high priest did. For modern background, Wikipedia and Bible Hub have reliable summaries.

Related people: Jesus, Pontius Pilate, Peter, John, Stephen, Paul, Herod the Great, Annas.

References and further reading

Public-domain books, free to read

Written by 508 Ministry. Scripture links open the public-domain World English Bible. Where Scripture, early church tradition and historians differ, this page says so.

↑